All news

Jackpot hopeful swears off lottery over confusing scratch-off font

A glitch with a lottery ticket left one Ohio player thinking he won $5K — instead, he won nothing.

James Lester pointing to the $2 “I'm Lucky and I Gnome It” scratch-off ticket that created this situation.
James Lester pointing to the $2 “I'm Lucky and I Gnome It” scratch-off ticket that created this situation. Photograph credit to News 5 Cleveland.
Todd Betzold

An Ohio man scratched his $2 “I'm Lucky and I Gnome It” ticket and thought his luck had finally turned around. Instead, his big $5,000 win vanished right before his eyes. Frustrated and seeking answers, the man found himself on an unexpected journey that led straight to the Ohio Lottery Commission, and eventually, the news.

The numbers on the ticket were difficult to read

About two weeks ago, James Lester said he bought a $2 “I'm Lucky and I Gnome It” scratch-off ticket from the Ohio Lottery. After scratching the ticket, the man thought he had won $5,000.

He wanted to make sure he had a winner, so he told WEWS, “I scanned it, and it said loser and I'm like, 'Oh no. My phone is tripping.'”

Lester was confused and wasted no time as he made his way back to the store where he purchased the ticket.

He told the media outlet, “I asked the gentleman, the regional manager down there, and I'm like, 'Sir, can you please tell me what this number is?'”

No one was providing answers

As it turns out, the regional manager couldn't provide him any answers on what the number was. Lester wasn't getting answers from anyone, so he said he reached out to the Ohio Lottery Commission and then eventually to WEWS in hopes of getting some kind of answer.

Lester said, “I've questioned it so far; I came to the news channel and that's bad.”

As it turns out, coming to the news channel finally provided him an answer to what happened.

WEWS reached out to the Ohio Lottery Commission on behalf of Lester, and they responded in an email saying:

The Ohio Lottery Commission received a complaint in late October that the numbers on the ticket were difficult to read clearly, so we decided it was best to reprint with a font that was cleaner. Tickets were reprinted, and sales reps are working to remove the old tickets from the field, but if the previously printed version was still sold it was still a valid ticket and would be paid if it were a winning ticket.

Things became more clear

After reprinting the ticket, it clearly showed Lester's ticket was, indeed, not a winner. He told WEWS, “I feel like I've been tricked.”

While Lester feels he has been tricked, the Ohio Lottery Commission advises any player who has a question about whether or not their ticket is a winner to scan the barcode or send it to the lottery headquarters to be reviewed by their claims office.

“I want them to print stuff and make sure it's plain as day for somebody,” said Lester. “It's just not fair.”

No more gambling

While Lester told WEWS that he has spent a lot of time and money gambling, this experience has changed that for him.

He said, “I quit playing the Ohio Lottery as of that day. Quit playing. Will not play Ohio Lottery again.”

While Lester claims he will not be playing the Ohio Lottery anymore, if you do, please remember to play responsibly.

Comments

0
Loading comments

Related articles

The hand of a customer hands over a credit card to the hand of a retailer.
A small lottery purchase ignites a big fight over fair play

Officials say tickets must be sold at face value. Are credit card fees on lottery sales legal?

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

Sloan Stanley of Meridian, Kansas, won $25,000 after playing the lottery for the first time.
High school jackpots: Lottery winners who struck it rich as teenagers

This 18-year-old won big with her first-ever lottery ticket.

Alex Cramer profile pic

Alex Cramer

A New Jersey Lottery machine.
The numbers behind New Jersey's broadest year of lottery wins

Every county saw meaningful wins in 2025, driven less by jackpots and more by steady prize volume.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

An abstract drawing of a person analyzing data and playing the lottery.
Why lottery players love systems, even when luck calls the shots

A spreadsheet helped one player win fast, but the real story may be why systems feel so powerful.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

Recent articles

View All
Jawed Areeb, accused of trying to claim a stolen Florida Lottery Fantasy 5 ticket.
The $115K Florida Lottery ticket was real, but the claim wasn't

Investigators say a lottery retailer stole a winning Fantasy 5 ticket and sent his nephew to claim the prize.

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The hand of a customer hands over a credit card to the hand of a retailer.
A small lottery purchase ignites a big fight over fair play

Officials say tickets must be sold at face value. Are credit card fees on lottery sales legal?

Todd Betzold profile pic

Todd Betzold

The Millionaire for Life logo in front of the Powerball and Mega Millions logo, with the word versus in between them.
With a new game looming, players ask: Lifetime prizes or big jackpots?

Winners could get $1 million a year for life in the new game. Is it worth playing?

 

Halley Bondy profile pic

Halley Bondy

Sloan Stanley of Meridian, Kansas, won $25,000 after playing the lottery for the first time.
High school jackpots: Lottery winners who struck it rich as teenagers

This 18-year-old won big with her first-ever lottery ticket.

Alex Cramer profile pic

Alex Cramer